“There was a lot of issues with the process, conflict of interest, and … approvals that I was seeking of who actually made decision wasn’t available,” he said.
“Something so tremendous and valuable to the City of Melbourne should be not only made in secret, and not only should be made by a few, but it should be actually made by those who are elected.”
Lord Mayor Nick Reece congratulates Robbie Williams in January after the singer was awarded the key to the city.Credit: Paul Jeffers
Le Liu said decisions of this significance should not be made by Reece and Leighton alone.
“It should be a decision of council so that we have transparency,” he said.
Being given a key to the city is a rare honour, with only 40 awarded in Melbourne’s history. Past recipients include Australian icon Olivia Newton-John, philanthropist Dame Elisabeth Murdoch, boxing legend Muhammad Ali and US country singer Dolly Parton.
Williams was the first person in seven years awarded the honour.
Reece said he supported the motion and thanked Le Liu for ensuring more robust processes were put in place.
“The general rule that council will be going forward with is that the more meaningful, symbolic and rare the award, the more robust and considered the decision-making process should be,” Reece said at the meeting on Monday night.
“We do want to ensure that when council does make the decision to give somebody an award, that the community can know that there’s been a robust process behind it.”
Reece said this was good governance and something that he strongly supported.
Loading
“I’m excited to explore more use of civic recognition awards over this council term,” he said. “When Robbie Williams was awarded the keys to the city earlier this year, it was a truly magic moment for this city.”
Councillor Gladys Liu attempted to move an amendment remove the award for LGBTIQA+ from the council’s Melbourne Awards on the basis that “the awards should be based on the contributions, the quality of the person, and it should not be based on sexuality”.
Her amendment was supported by councillor Owen Guest but rejected by all other councillors.
Councillor Davydd Griffiths said Liu’s proposed amendment was horrible and warned it risked “unlocking the culture wars here at Town Hall”.
Loading
The council meeting also considered the City of Melbourne’s draft budget and $4.5 million of increased funding for bike lanes after the council received more than 1450 submissions from angry cyclists who said Reece had breached his election promise to maintain funding for cycling infrastructure.
Reece said the updated four-year investment meant that the total put in by the city to cycling infrastructure was in line with the council’s previous term.
“We’ve heard loud and clear about the importance of cycling safety, with close to 11 deaths on Melbourne roads from cycling accidents,” Reece said.
“So whether that is protected bike lanes, green bike lanes, better lighting at intersections, there is a whole range of interventions that are there that can improve cyclist safety and ensure that all users of our transport system feel safe.”
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
