A referendum in Switzerland to decide whether to introduce electronic identity cards has taken place, with initial projections suggesting voters are evenly split.
It is the second nationwide ballot on the issue, after the idea was rejected in 2021 over data protection concerns and unease over the proposed system being largely run by private firms.
Under the revised proposal, the new system would remain entirely optional and in public hands, with data stored on users’ smartphones rather than centrally.
It comes as the UK government this week announced plans to introduce its own digital ID as part of efforts to curb the number of illegal migrants living and working in the country.
The proposed British digital ID would have fewer intended uses, but has still raised concerns about privacy and data security.
Switzerland’s plan has already been approved by both its houses of parliament, and the Swiss government recommends a “Yes” vote.
Citizens can still choose to rely on a physical national identity card, which has been standard in Switzerland for decades.
To ease privacy concerns, a particular authority seeking information on a person – such as proof of age or nationality, for example – will only be able to check for those specific details.
Supporters say the system will make life much easier for everyone, allowing a range of bureaucratic procedures – from getting a telephone contract to proving you’re old enough to buy a bottle of wine – to happen quickly online.
But Switzerland has a long tradition of protecting its citizens’ privacy. The banking secrecy laws, now much diluted, were designed to shield an individual’s personal finances from the prying eyes of the state.
For years, Google Street View was controversial in Switzerland – and even today, following a ruling by the Swiss Federal Court, images taken close to schools, women’s refuges, hospitals or prisons must be automatically blurred before going online.
There are also far fewer CCTV cameras in Switzerland than in many of its European neighbours.
Opponents of digital ID cards, who gathered enough signatures to force another referendum on the issue, argue that this measure could still undermine individual privacy.
They also fear that, despite the new restrictions on how data is collected and stored, it could still be used to track people and for marketing purposes.
An early projection while voting continues suggests a 50-50 split over the issue, making the final result – expected late on Sunday – too close to call.
Opinion polls heading into the referendum suggested voters may be ready to give electronic IDs a chance.
They have already had experience of the government’s Covid ID, which was used during the pandemic to show vaccination status and was mandatory to enter restaurants and bars.
And as for the concerns about marketing of personal data, most Swiss have smartphones and are keen users of social media.
Tech giants are already harvesting their likes and dislikes, so many voters believe that allowing the Swiss authorities to check on a few details from time to time will not make a big difference.
